Beware the Arson Firefighter: Social Org Charts and the Five Whos

Superintendent calmly reviewing a stable takt plan while a 'crisis' email pops up on a laptop
Read 8 min

This is our second assortment. These concepts weren’t long enough for standalone posts, but I’m in the habit of writing down anything amazing, not just good or great, the moment I hear it so I can share it with you. Most of these came from walking with Kevin and Fabien in France.

Short answer: Look past the written org chart to the social one. Ask the five whys, not the five whos. Beware the arson firefighter, who starts the fire to play the hero, because the greatest leaders are stable and prevent problems. And always know the purpose of the project, because purpose centered on respecting people works every time.

Who Is Really Leading the Team?

Fabien said there’s always the written organizational chart, and then there’s the social organizational chart. In his consulting, he always has to find out what’s really going on. The superintendent, project manager, and hierarchy may be written on the org chart, and you could assume that’s how things work. But you always have to find the real story behind the scenes.

Factor Question to ask
Influence Who has influence with the people? To some degree, they’re the real leader.
Connection Who has the connection and trust, and is being listened to?
Communication Who has the most seamless, effective communication pathways? They’re closer to implementable authority.
Proximity Who has the closest proximity to the people? That’s a big one.

Here’s an example. Some would say the father presides over the home, some the mother, some both equally. I’m in the both-equally camp. But by influence, connection, communication, and proximity, Katie has more. She’s the CEO and does a lot of work, but she isn’t traveling as much. When dad says to do something, the kids look over at mom: do you sanction this? The reality is Katie’s in charge. You’ll find the same with Katie and Kevin in our organization. Even with my COO title, there’s always a social org chart. When you analyze teams, come into groups, or look at your projects, ask: am I talking to the right person? Am I talking to the leader?

Are You Asking the Five Whys or the Five Whos?

I’d never heard this. You know the five whys, or seven whys: when you have a problem, you ask why five times, why did this happen, why is that true, until you get to the root cause. But Fabien said most people ask the five whos. Who did this? Who did that? They seek to blame the person instead of the process, system, behavior, or culture.

It’s not funny in reality, but I giggled. In The Prince of Egypt, after Moses kills the guard on top of the scaffolding, a guard looks up and says, who did this? Every time something bad happens, somebody says, who did this? I’d like to see it written, posted, sketched, and publicized: don’t focus on the five whos.

What Is an Arson Firefighter?

I asked Fabien who his biggest detractors are. This doesn’t come from arrogance. I’m just doing my best at what I was called to do. But there are people copying our material, taking credit for concepts, and trying to poach our people because they’re so well trained. Fabien said he couldn’t mention anyone specifically. Things like people leaving to start their own business with your material used to bother him, but now they don’t, because it spreads the message. Wow, this guy is super mature. Another is companies that delegate lean, which we’ve talked about. See Things You Cannot Delegate as a CEO.

But his biggest detractor is the arson firefighter. Because of a need or a desire for significance, on the public stage, on a project, or wherever, this person, whether a project manager, a third-party consultant, or someone on social media, starts a fire and is magically the only one who can put it out. They scare you: oh my gosh, we have a huge problem on the project, we’re behind schedule. Then they come in to fight the fire and be the hero. It happens to him on projects sometimes.

He said it’s not the people who leave and start companies, not the people taking information, not even the people not taking lean seriously. It’s the ones who cause problems on projects and then play the savior, because at a fundamental level, they don’t know what they’re doing, they don’t know how to create stability, and they don’t have the recognition they want.

Who Are the Real Heroes?

If someone is always saying, I’m going to go save this, they’ve got a big problem, I’ll have to go down there next week, always playing the savior, the firefighter, the hero, be careful. They may be causing more problems than they solve. The greatest leaders are stable. They have even-keeled, balanced organizations. They prevent problems. Read We Never Firefight.

Hero Not a hero
People in a war defending their country You create the emergency and you firefight it
Firefighters who didn’t start the fire You create the emergency and come save it
First responders to an actual emergency You create the problem and then come fix it

Why Does Purpose Come First?

This theme hits me over and over: every question needs to be answered with, what is the purpose of the project? What is the charter, the conditions of satisfaction, the goal, the clarity document? What does the owner want? That should be brought into the schedule, the way of doing business, the teaming, and the orientations, aligned all the way through the worker ranks. Otherwise, no really clear decisions can be made. See Conditions of Satisfaction: The Blueprint for Success.

People call me all the time wanting to implement lean, get our services, or pursue operational excellence. I love these people. The first thing I always ask is, what problem are you trying to solve? What is your purpose, your goal, your vision? Here’s the pattern: any time the purpose centers on respecting people, it works every time. When it’s I heard I’m supposed to do this, I’ll delegate it, I want to make another buck, or my superior told me to, it never works.

If people connect and identify with the purpose of a project, you can get them to do amazing things. If the project has a bad purpose, why would anyone want to be part of it? It’s like Braveheart: I didn’t come here to die so they can get more land and get rich. People want to know what they’re doing matters: a hospital that will cure cancer for kids, a lab researching the next wonder drug, a school for underprivileged children, or a project that will respect workers and change the industry.

So here is the challenge. Sketch the social org chart for your project. Then check whether the people with the most influence know the purpose of the project.

Bottom line: Find the real leaders, blame the process not the person, be stable instead of a hero, and know the purpose of your project.

If your project needs superintendent coaching, project support, or leadership development, Elevate Construction can help your field teams stabilize, schedule, and flow.

On we go.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an arson firefighter on a construction project?

Fabien’s term for a project manager, third-party consultant, or person on social media who, out of a need for significance, starts a fire and is then magically the only one who can put it out, playing the hero. At a fundamental level, they don’t know how to create stability.

What is the social organizational chart?

Behind the written org chart there’s a social one that may not be written down. It shows who has the most influence, connection and trust, the most effective communication pathways, and the closest proximity to the people. That person is, to some degree, the real leader.

What are the five whos?

Instead of asking why five times to blame the process, system, behavior, or culture, people ask who did this, who did that, seeking to blame a person. Ask the five whys, not the five whos.

People Also Read:
Conditions Of Satisfaction
You Are the Hero
Ikigai for Builders: Finding Purpose in Your Work Every Day
How to Win Friends and Influence People

If you want to learn more we have:

-Takt Virtual Training: (Takt Virtual Training)
-Check out our YouTube channel for more info: (Elevate Construction on YouTube)
-Listen to the Elevate Construction podcast: (Elevate Construction Podcast)
-Check out our training programs and certifications: (Training Programs and Certifications)
-The Takt Book: (The Takt Book on Amazon)

Discover Jason’s Expertise:

Meet Jason Schroeder, the driving force behind Elevate Construction. As the company’s Founder and COO, he’s dedicated to taking construction to new heights. With a wealth of industry experience, he’s crafted the Field Engineer Boot Camp and Superintendent Boot Camp – intensive training programs engineered to cultivate top-tier leaders capable of steering their teams towards success. Jason’s vision? To expand his training initiatives across the nation, empowering construction firms to soar to unprecedented levels of excellence.

Share:

    Share Link