It’s really nice to be with competent and professional lean leaders throughout the industry. Last week in France, Fabien at Timote, one of the founding lean experts in that country, told Kevin and me about a study they did themselves. I can’t remember how many sample groups. They studied how many times a foreman is interrupted throughout the day on an average project: a phone call, a worker asking for something, a change, a distraction, anything. The answer was an average of every six minutes.
Short answer: Foremen are interrupted an average of every six minutes, and every interruption costs context-switching time. The answer isn’t to figure it out when you get there. Go with a plan and stabilize your systems, through pull plans, foreman huddles, predictable deliveries, orientation, visual boards, and crew preparation huddles, so the time between interruptions grows from six minutes to 10, 15, 30, or an hour.
What Does Context Switching Cost?
We’ve talked extensively on this podcast about context switching. If I switched from doing a podcast to talking to my wife on the phone, that might be three minutes of added time. Not a huge deal. But if I’m creating a schedule, making a plan, or doing layout with a mental focus, and an engineer comes up or a worker says, hey, I need help over here, that could be up to 15 minutes of context switching. On a big project, switching complete gears for the crew could be 45.
Context switching is where you switch your mental focus into a new context. Human brains aren’t computers, and even the smartest of us take extra time to get back into the frame of the work at hand. So being interrupted every six minutes is a pretty big deal. Add the travel time, the phone and radio time, the motion, and stopping to pack up your computer or shut your gang box, and you’re adding a considerable amount of time.
What Would It Be Worth to Stretch Six Minutes?
What Fabien was saying is that this study leads us to believe that allowing foremen to focus is a huge concept. So let me ask you some questions. When I say increase the number, I mean if a foreman is interrupted every six minutes, 10 minutes is better, 15 is better, a half hour is better, an hour is better. We want the foreman interrupted less, while everyone still has what they need.
| If you have… | Does it stretch the six minutes? |
|---|---|
| Afternoon foreman huddles where foremen collaborate on, focus on, and commit to a plan they can see | Yes. What’s that worth to you? |
| Predictable material deliveries, leveled on a digital schedule, with the forklift and crane available | Could you go from six to eight, or six to 10? |
| Workers completely oriented to the project, who know exactly what the work is | Maybe 10 to 12 |
| Visual quality and feature-of-work boards that all workers can see | Fewer little questions for the foreman |
| Crew preparation huddles: plan for the day, lists, 5S or 3S, pre-task plans, quality deliverables, everyone lined out and trained | Yes |
A lot of times people think, I’ll figure it out when I get there. That’s a faulty way of thinking. Don’t figure it out when you get there. Go with a plan and stabilize your systems, so the number of interruptions goes down and the time between them goes up. See Out of Your Head, Off of Your Shoulders: The Afternoon Foreman Huddle.
Does a Month, Week, and Day in the Life Reduce Interruptions?
This is bonus content. I’m going through Elevating Construction Foremen, or Elevating Construction Crew Leaders, which has a section on a month, a week, and a day in the life of a crew leader. Go through it with the six minutes in mind:
- The pull plan? Yes, because you have the right sequence.
- A quality pre-construction meeting with the foremen? Yes, because now it’s on a visual board.
- Foremen taking time to study the drawings and specs? Yes, because there’s less rework.
- Communicated safety and quality expectations? Absolutely.
- Work made ready ahead of time with fewer roadblocks? Yes.
- A weekly work plan? Yes. A day plan? Yes.
- A foreman morning routine and the right frame of mind? Yes.
- Workers oriented in worker huddles? Yes. Crew preparation huddle? Yes.
- A safety pre-task plan? Yes.
- Instructions to workers in lists, bullets, or a visual manner? Yes.
- Continual training and mentoring? Yes.
- An after-lunch check-in to make sure crews are off to the right start? Yes.
- Cleanup and making sure the next day is prepped? Yes.
Why Are There So Many Meetings?
When somebody says, Jason, these are a lot of meetings and a lot of things, why would I do that, let’s just get by, here’s why. We’re attempting to reduce the number of times the foreman is interrupted. We’re trying to reduce context switching. We want good, productive, focused, one-piece, one-process flow work. See The Crew Preparation Huddle.
Every six minutes, your foremen are interrupted. Think about that before you design a system or take actions that create more variation for them.
What Did France Teach Us?
Kevin and I were in France meeting with Fabien and the Timote team, mapping out opportunities and potential interaction in the future. We learned so much, ran ourselves into the ground on about four hours of sleep a night, which I’m not proud of, and still got to see the Champs-Élysées, the Louvre, and the Eiffel Tower, taking the subway all over. I came back with a list of probably 15 podcasts I want to do from what I learned. It’s so great to be around mentors like Fabien.
A listener wrote that what we’re doing makes our field a better place and brings out the best in people who want to be better and change the game, and that until he makes it to a class, he’ll keep reading the books and listening. Hopefully it’s making a difference. We only have about 15 more bits of feedback to share on the podcast, so please keep it coming.
So here is the challenge. Shadow one of your foremen for an hour this week and count the interruptions. Then pick one system from the list above that would remove the most common one.
Bottom line: Your foremen are interrupted every six minutes. Go with a plan and stabilize your systems so they can focus.
If your project needs superintendent coaching, project support, or leadership development, Elevate Construction can help your field teams stabilize, schedule, and flow.
On we go.
FAQ
How often are foremen interrupted?
In a study Fabien at Timote described, foremen on an average project were interrupted an average of every six minutes, by phone calls, workers asking for something, changes, or distractions.
How much time does context switching cost?
A small switch might add about three minutes. Switching from focused work like a schedule, a plan, or layout can add up to 15 minutes, and switching gears for a whole crew on a big project could be 45, before travel, phone, radio, and packing up are added.
Why do lean systems have so many meetings?
To reduce how often the foreman is interrupted and the context switching that follows. Pull plans, foreman huddles, predictable deliveries, worker orientation, visual boards, crew preparation huddles, and day plans all stretch the time between interruptions so crews get focused, one-piece flow work.
People Also Read:
Afternoon Foreman Huddles
Crew Preparation Huddles
Distraction and Stress Is Fear
Lean Onboarding Series – The Crew Preparation Huddle
If you want to learn more we have:
-Takt Virtual Training: (Takt Virtual Training)
-Check out our YouTube channel for more info: (Elevate Construction on YouTube)
-Listen to the Elevate Construction podcast: (Elevate Construction Podcast)
-Check out our training programs and certifications: (Training Programs and Certifications)
-The Takt Book: (The Takt Book on Amazon)
Discover Jason’s Expertise:
Meet Jason Schroeder, the driving force behind Elevate Construction. As the company’s Founder and COO, he’s dedicated to taking construction to new heights. With a wealth of industry experience, he’s crafted the Field Engineer Boot Camp and Superintendent Boot Camp – intensive training programs engineered to cultivate top-tier leaders capable of steering their teams towards success. Jason’s vision? To expand his training initiatives across the nation, empowering construction firms to soar to unprecedented levels of excellence.