Your Motive Determines the Leader You Will Become
At some point in every construction career, a quiet question shows up. It usually arrives disguised as opportunity. A promotion. A new title. More money. More responsibility. On the surface, it looks like the obvious next step. But underneath, there is a deeper question that rarely gets asked out loud: Why do I want to be a leader?
That question matters more than skill, experience, or ambition. In fact, it matters so much that it will ultimately determine whether leadership becomes the most fulfilling chapter of your career or the most frustrating one.
The Hidden Tension in Construction Career Paths
In construction, leadership progression often feels automatic. A strong craft professional becomes a lead. A lead becomes a foreman. A foreman becomes a superintendent. In the office, the path runs from project engineer to project manager to executive roles. These paths are familiar, expected, and often unexamined.
The problem is not progression. The problem is assumption. We assume that because someone is good at doing, they will enjoy leading. We assume that because leadership comes with status or pay, it must be the goal. We assume there is only one definition of success.
Those assumptions quietly push people into roles they may not want, may not enjoy, and may not be suited for. That is how good builders become miserable leaders, and how teams suffer without anyone quite knowing why.
The Shift That Changes Everything
When I stepped into my first role as a project superintendent, I had to make a fundamental shift. I moved from being a doer to being responsible for people. That transition was not intuitive. It was learned.
Books by Patrick Lencioni helped me understand something critical. Leadership is not about control or prestige. It is about service. It is about spending most of your time doing the things others cannot or will not do, especially when those things are uncomfortable.
As a doer, your value comes from execution. As a leader, your value comes from developing others. That shift requires a completely different motive.
Two Motives That Drive Leadership
When people pursue leadership, their motivation usually falls into one of two categories. The first is service. The desire to help others succeed, to build teams, to create clarity, and to take responsibility for the health of the organization. This motive pulls leaders toward people, even when it is difficult.
The second motive is reward. This includes money, title, authority, recognition, or control. This motive pulls leaders toward comfort. When the reward motive dominates, leaders tend to focus on what they enjoy and avoid what leadership actually requires.
That distinction matters because leadership work is rarely comfortable. If your motive is reward, you will eventually resent the role. If your motive is service, the hard parts will still be hard, but they will feel meaningful.
What Leadership Actually Requires
There is a misconception that leadership is easier than doing. In reality, it is harder in a different way. Leadership requires emotional effort, courage, and consistency. It demands that you enter situations most people avoid.
In healthy organizations and projects, leaders spend much of their time on work that never appears on a schedule or cost report.
- Building and developing the leadership team so the organization can function without heroics
- Managing direct reports through clarity, feedback, and accountability rather than avoidance
These responsibilities do not produce instant gratification. They require patience, repetition, and humility. That is why motive matters so much.
The Work Leaders Try to Avoid
In my experience, there are certain responsibilities leaders consistently try to abdicate once they reach a position of authority. Not because they are unimportant, but because they are uncomfortable.
Having difficult conversations is one of the most avoided duties in leadership. Correcting behavior, addressing hygiene, professionalism, communication style, or performance issues feels personal. But avoiding those conversations does not make the problem go away. It transfers the cost to the team.
Running effective meetings is another responsibility leaders often dismiss. Poor meetings drain energy, waste time, and signal a lack of care. Well-run meetings create alignment, engagement, and trust. Meetings reflect leadership health.
Communication is the final responsibility that separates effective leaders from overwhelmed ones. Leaders must communicate constantly, clearly, and repetitively. Whether introverted or extroverted, leaders must scale communication so people know the mission, the priorities, and how they are winning.
Why So Many Leaders Struggle
Most leadership failure in construction does not come from a lack of knowledge. People know how to build. They know how to schedule. They know how to manage budgets. What stops them is fear.
Fear of conflict.
Fear of being disliked.
Fear of awkward conversations.
That fear leads to avoidance, and avoidance creates confusion, resentment, and turnover. People do not usually leave companies. They leave leaders who will not engage with them.
If holding people accountable feels unbearable, leadership may not be the right path. And that is not a failure. The industry needs experts just as much as it needs leaders.
Making Space for Different Kinds of Excellence
One of the healthiest shifts construction can make is creating respect for multiple career paths. Not everyone needs to lead people to have a meaningful, successful career. Technical mastery, craftsmanship, and expertise are just as valuable.
True elevation of the industry happens when people are encouraged to pursue roles that align with their strengths and motives. Forcing leadership on someone who does not want it helps no one.
The Daily Reality of Leadership
Leadership teams are not calm, quiet places. They are environments of debate, accountability, and high standards. They require people to speak up, challenge ideas, and own decisions. That discomfort is not a sign of dysfunction. It is a sign of health when handled well.
If you are drawn to leadership, you must be willing to live in that tension. You must be willing to stretch beyond your comfort zone, repeatedly.
And if your project needs superintendent coaching, project support, or leadership development, Elevate Construction can help your field teams stabilize, schedule, and flow.
Learning as a Leadership Discipline
One habit consistently separates strong leaders from stagnant ones. They read. They learn. They invest in their thinking. Leadership is not a fixed trait. It is a practiced skill.
Continuous learning expands perspective, improves decision-making, and increases value. Over time, it compounds into better outcomes, better teams, and greater fulfillment. The return on that investment is real, both professionally and personally.
Conclusion: Choose the Path That Brings Fulfillment
Leadership is not about arriving. It is about serving. It is about doing the things no one else can or will do, day after day, for the benefit of others.
Before pursuing leadership, pause and examine your motive. Ask whether you want the responsibility, not just the reward. Ask whether you are willing to lead people instead of tasks. Ask whether fulfillment, not status, is your goal.
As Patrick Lencioni teaches, and as experience confirms, success without fulfillment is the ultimate failure. Choose the path that allows you to contribute fully, grow honestly, and respect yourself and others.
As Jason Schroeder often reminds leaders, “The hardest work in leadership is not building the project. It is building the people.”
FAQs
What is the main message of leadership motive in construction?
Leadership should be pursued for service and responsibility, not for title, money, or status.
Is it okay to choose not to become a leader?
Yes. Technical experts and doers are essential, and fulfillment matters more than hierarchy.
Why do leaders struggle with accountability?
Fear of conflict and discomfort often prevent leaders from having necessary conversations.
How does reading and learning impact leadership success?
Continuous learning expands perspective, improves judgment, and increases long-term value.
How can Elevate Construction support leadership development?
Through coaching, training, and project support that focuses on people, systems, and sustainable performance.
If you want to learn more we have:
-Takt Virtual Training: (Click here)
-Check out our Youtube channel for more info: (Click here)
-Listen to the Elevate Construction podcast: (Click here)
-Check out our training programs and certifications: (Click here)
-The Takt Book: (Click here)
Discover Jason’s Expertise:
Meet Jason Schroeder, the driving force behind Elevate Construction IST. As the company’s owner and principal consultant, he’s dedicated to taking construction to new heights. With a wealth of industry experience, he’s crafted the Field Engineer Boot Camp and Superintendent Boot Camp – intensive training programs engineered to cultivate top-tier leaders capable of steering their teams towards success. Jason’s vision? To expand his training initiatives across the nation, empowering construction firms to soar to unprecedented levels of excellence.